|
29 March 2026 · Issue 02
|
~6 min read
|
|
|
A POLYMATH publication
THE DEBRIEF.
Consumer brand intelligence, every Sunday.
|
|
|
Premiumisation has been the lazy bet in consumer for a decade. Whatever you sold, sell a more expensive version. Whatever your AOV was, push it 8%. The market did the work. This week is the first week the data made me question whether that thesis still holds.
Three premium brands posted softer Q1 numbers in the same five-day window. Aesop down 4% volume, full Estee Lauder reporting. Khaite tested a 6% price rise in March; same-store conversion dropped 11 points. Belvedere voluntarily dropped a £52 SKU back to £45 after Q4 trade data showed shelf-share collapsing. None of these are bad brands. They're the canaries.
The story isn't that premium is dead. The story is that the price elasticity equation flipped while everyone was still pricing on the 2019 curve. People who used to buy two are now buying one. Average basket up, full-price units flat. That's a margin event dressed up as a healthy headline number. Scroll down.
|
|
|
Lucy x
|
|
|
On your radar
The Headlines.
|
beauty |
Aesop volume down 4% YoY in Q1, per Estée Lauder reporting. Average basket up 7%, full-price units flat to negative. The premium fragrance plateau the category whispered about all autumn now visible in audited numbers. LVMH IR → |
Charlotte Tilbury quietly introduces a £28 lipstick, £7 below the brand's prior floor. Not a markdown. A new tier. The brand is signalling it can no longer hold the customer above its old entry price without ceding share to Mecca's own labels. Drapers → |
consumer brands |
Khaite raises prices 6% in March; same-store conversion drops 11%. The first quarter where the elasticity bit at the top end of premium denim. Roughly £42M of US revenue ran through this test, and it's the cleanest data point we've seen. WWD → |
food and beverage |
Daylesford Organic introduces a £4.50 own-label pasta below its £6.80 line. The first time the brand has anchored a tier below the existing range. Reads as an explicit defence of basket size against M&S Food's premium-pasta push. The Grocer → |
drink |
Belvedere drops a £52 SKU back to £45 after Q4 shelf-share data. A voluntary price cut from a premium spirits brand that historically raised, never dropped. The walk-back is the news; the new price is the data. The Spirits Business → |
capital |
Permira closes a £1.4B premium-tier consumer fund and quietly broadens its mandate. The new mandate explicitly includes £40 to £80 RRP brands, what the market used to call ‘everyday luxury’. The size of the cheque follows where the volume sits. Financial Times → |
|
|
Behind the curtain
The Strategy.
|
|
Where the price ceiling actually lives in your category
Two SKUs at every tier. Or you have a margin problem.
The reason premium brands are getting hit isn't that customers stopped wanting premium. It's that nobody designed the range for what happens when the customer flinches. If you have one SKU at £80 and the customer baulks at £80, you lose the order. If you have a £64 SKU and an £80 SKU, the £64 one catches the basket and the £80 one frames the value of the £64. That framing is most of the work.
The brands holding pricing this year all share one design principle. They have at least two SKUs at every tier they want to defend, and the gap between tiers is between 18% and 32%. Outside that band the customer either trades down too far or doesn't see the difference.
The Numbers.
Premium fragrance £200 ceiling Volume falls off above this RRP across UK department stores. | Skincare serum £80 ceiling The threshold above which conversion drops by ~22 points. | Premium denim £350 ceiling Khaite's 6% test landed just above; conversion broke first. | Tier gap 18% – 32% The price gap that frames a higher tier without losing the lower. |
* Thresholds derived from category-level conversion data across UK retail; ranges illustrative, not absolute.
|
If your range has only one price tier, you have a margin problem the day inflation lands. You also have a brand problem, because the customer can't compare. People understand value relatively, not absolutely. A £64 product feels expensive; a £64 product next to an £80 one feels like a sensible decision.
The brands that win this year aren't the ones at the top of the price ladder. They're the ones that built three rungs of it, with two SKUs at each. Polymath research →
|
|
|
Key insight
The Take.
Premiumisation isn't dead. It's not 2019 anymore. The brands that win this year aren't the ones at the top of the price ladder, they're the ones that built three rungs of it.
|
|
|
Inside the work
The Practice.
|
|
From my desk
Modelled a UK tea brand's price elasticity across three retailers this fortnight. The £4.99 SKU drives volume; the £8.50 SKU drives margin. Killing one tanks the other. What surprised the founder: the £8.50 SKU sold a third more units when the £4.99 was on shelf next to it.
|
For your business
If your range has one price tier, you have a single point of failure on margin. The fix isn't a discount. It's a second SKU. Build the cheaper version that frames the more expensive one. The customer will tell you which side of the fence they're on, and they'll pay for the privilege.
|
|
|
|
In conversation with
The Founder.
|
Anita Daniels · Wild & Stone
|
Anita Daniels, Wild & Stone.
From a kitchen-table side hustle to listings across Waitrose, John Lewis and Amazon UK. We talked about why she runs three price tiers across the same product family and the moment her finance director realised the cheapest SKU was paying for the most expensive.
Anita is unusually disciplined about the relationship between range and shelf. Most founders think price; she thinks shelf adjacency. The bamboo toothbrush sits next to two other tiers, both Wild & Stone, both her margin.
What she said about pricing as a brand exercise, not a commercial one, will reframe how you look at your next launch. Read the full feature on LinkedIn →
|
|
|
|
That's the week. Hit reply with the price your category can no longer hold.
Lucy x
|
|
| |
|
01
Chat to us.
A 30-minute call to talk through what's leaking, what's under-leveraged and what's worth a closer look in your business. No pitch, just numbers.
Book a call →
|
|
| |
|
02
Run The Scan.
A two-week deep-dive into your P&L, unit economics, channel mix and operating model. Tells you where the value is, where it's leaking and what to fix first.
Learn more →
|
|
|
|
Growth partner for consumer brands
POLYMATH
The commercial intelligence behind your brand.
Business · Management · Consulting
|
|
|
You built the brand. Now build the business behind it.
|
|
|
|